City launches tree inventory to get a handle on situation
By Ed Nadolski
Editor in chief
It was only a matter of time, according to officials, but word came down late last week confirming the presence of the ash tree-destroying emerald ash borer in the City of Burlington.
With the invasive pest confirmed at other locations throughout Racine, Kenosha and Walworth counties – all of which are under a state firewood quarantine – public works officials in the city knew it would be a just matter of time before the emerald ash borer (EAB, for short) was found within the city limits.
“We’ve been peeling bark and looking at downed limbs for the last year or so,” said Craig Workman, director of public works for the city, on efforts to find and identify the EAB.
On Friday the state Department of Natural Resources confirmed that photos of the boring trails under the bark on city-owned trees were indeed the insidious work of the EAB.
Once an area receives confirmation, the goal is limiting the destructive impact of the EAB because there is currently no way to eradicate it.
According to Workman, DPW staff is in the process of a citywide tree survey. That should be complete sometime in August
“From there, we’ll have a better idea of the number of ash trees the city owns and their health,” he said.
That information will provide the basis for the city’s mitigation strategy, which typically includes the removal of dead and dying ash trees and the treating of trees that are likely to survive, Workman said.
The strategy will also include any preventative measures for unaffected ash trees.
According to a press release posted on the city’s website, the strategy will be to determine the most cost-effective methods of removing and treating ash trees within the city limits.
Workman said more information will be available to the public once the mitigation strategy is finished.
According to the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection, there currently is no way to stop the spread of or eradicate the EAB.
City officials encourage residents concerned with the condition of an ash tree on their property to contact a tree service familiar with the EAB or a certified arborist. A listing of certified arborists may be found on the Wisconsin Arborist Association website at www.waa-isa.org.
Although city ordinances require residents to remove diseased and dying trees, Workman said the city won’t be cracking down any time soon.
“At this point the city isn’t going into a major enforcement mode,” he said. “We’ve got plenty of our own trees to worry about.”
Officials caution residents that there may be companies traveling to the Burlington area looking to scam ash tree owners or inflate prices for tree services in light of this week’s announcement. Residents with ash trees on their properties are encouraged review the state EAB websites to understand their options before contracting with any tree service company or arborist.
The state maintains a website dedicated to the EAB at https://datcpservices.wisconsin.gov/eab/index.jsp.
Here are a few facts about the EAB from the website:
• The metallic green beetle is native to East Asia. It was brought to the United States accidentally, in the wood of shipping crates from China.
• EAB is not a threat to human health but it kills native ash trees of any size, any age, healthy or unhealthy.
• The larva spends its life inside ash trees, feeding on the inner bark. This feeding disrupts the trees’ ability to move water and nutrients back and forth from the roots to the rest of the tree. The tree starves and eventually dies.
• A tree that has been attacked by EAB can die within 2-4 years. Researchers estimate that more than 50 million ash trees are dead or dying in the Midwest because of this insect.
• Wisconsin forests contain more than 770 million ash trees, nearly 7 percent of the tree population. In urban areas, we estimate that, on average, 20 percent of trees are ash.
• EAB moves far by hitching rides. On its own, the beetle will only fly a few miles. However, it is easily and quickly moved to new areas when people accidentally move emerald ash borer larvae inside of infested firewood, ash nursery stock, and other ash items.
Because the area is under quarantine, it is illegal to transport ash tree materials and hardwood firewood to non-quarantined areas without a special permit from the state.
Here in Missouri the EPA and Missouri Conservation are attempting to control this infestation. Unfortunately the firewood business in SE Missouri has decided that rather than abide by the law restricting the movement of wood they circumvent the law by moving their product into adjacent counties and distribute from there. Mulch is another matter entirely and there are currently no controls on that. This is a serious problem, but I am not sure that the acceptance of lawlessness isn’t more of an issue. In Missouri all of the beautiful ash trees that surrounded the Arch were cut down to avert the problem. Much effort and expense have been put forward, but there is a portion of the population that wants to do what they want to do whenever they want to do it and the law be damned. They are too stupid to understand the problem so therefore it does not exist or does not apply to them. A classic confusion of liberty and license. I would add that technology does not make us smarter. It provides more powerful tools for stupidity. The ash trees will be destroyed partly due to the insects, but mostly because of the stupid.
Well, just earlier this Yr, the Big Foot State Park cut down alot of it’s Trees because of this I understand.
As with other Tree speciese that have succumed to Diseases, we just have to Cut them down and Replace them with Other Species.
Silver Lining..
And it’s good Windfall for the Tree Cutting Business in very tough times, is it not? Creates some Nice paying Jobs, does it not?
Tree stump removal business is Going well too , I assume..
As for Prevention? That doesn’t Equate in most Towns Budgets.. They have to justify the costs and that usually comes After a Problem Occures..
Much like they have to wait till several Serious Accidents before they can justify the Costs of Putting up a Stop Lite.. It’s not their Fault,it’s just the way it is..
Would you have aggreed to pay another $50 yr for PreTreating the Ash Trees in your Town on your Real Estate Bill? Did oyu pay several hundred to have the one’s On your Own Property Done? Why Not?
Can cost $500 to cut a Large one down and Stump Removal and then another $200 to Plant a New Smaller Tree and take several Yrs to Get Big again..
Pay at leat $700 for that or how much to Pre Treat your Tree for how many yrs it has to be done?
We had a Large one cut down and stump removed for $300 Plus another $150 to Buy and Plant another Different Tree, that will take at least 5 yrs to Get a Decent size again.. So that’s $450 just for that one tree problem..